Insanity Defense facts
While investigating facts about Insanity Defense Cases and Insanity Defense Statistics, I found out little known, but curios details like:
In 1857, a congressman from New York killed the U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia over the attorney's affair with his wife. He claimed temporary insanity (thanks to his wife's infidelity), the first time this defense was used in U.S. history. He was acquitted.
how often is the insanity defense used?
Harry Thaw who killed architect Stanford White and was acquitted based on the defense of "dementia Americana," a phenomenon that caused American men to become temporarily insane and seek revenge against those who had tainted their wives’ virtue. Thaw had married White's former mistress.
What are the four types of insanity defenses?
In my opinion, it is useful to put together a list of the most interesting details from trusted sources that I've come across answering what is the standard for the insanity defense in virginia. Here are 14 of the best facts about Insanity Defense Definition and Insanity Defense Reform Act I managed to collect.
what's insanity defense?
-
'The Matrix defense'. A form of The Insanity Defence in which the defendant claims that they committed a crime because they believed they were in the Matrix. i.e: "This isn’t even the real world, man. How can I actually commit a crime?"
-
Gay panic", in which a defendant denies legal culpability due to temporary insanity over unwanted gay sexual advances, has been used as a successful defense against assault & murder charges in several countries
-
4 states in the US don't allow an 'insanity defense'
-
The first person to use the temporary insanity defense in court was Daniel Sickles, a Civil War solider, and a US Politician in the 1860's who had killed his wife's lover.
-
About the "gay/trans panic defense," which can be used in assault and murder cases to get a lesser charge/sentence by claiming that the defendant acted in a state of violent temporary insanity because of unwanted same-sex sexual advances.
-
The "insanity defense" goes back as far as the Code of Hammurabi thousands of years ago. The insane were given exemption from full criminal prosecution.
-
The first person to use the Temporary Insanity Defense was a Congressman who murdered the son of the composer of "The Star Spangled Banner”
-
The concept of "settled insanity" has evolved as a defense in U.S. courts. Most jurisdictions recognize that the long-term use of an intoxicant can cause "settled insanity" that can serve as a defense to a criminal act and includes, e.g., the delirium tremens caused by alcohol withdrawal.
Why insanity defense should be allowed?
You can easily fact check reasons why insanity defense is good by examining the linked well-known sources.
The Gay Panic Defense: a legitimate legal defense in many jurisdictions whereby those accused of assault or murder are said to have been provoked into intense fear and insanity by the victim's homosexuality.
A man in San Francisco had lost his job and killed several people on a shooting spree. He pled insanity, using the defense that sugar made him unable to reason, now called the Twinkie Defense, and his penalty was lessened. - source
